Category: Patek Philippe

The Evolution of the Replica Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712 – PPF/ZF vs. SW vs. ACE Movement

The Evolution of the Replica Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712 – PPF/ZF vs. SW vs. ACE Movement

The Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712 has undergone significant improvements in the replica market, primarily driven by PPF (also known as ZF). This collaboration has resulted in one of the most refined super clone watches available today, making it a top seller in 2024—even surpassing replicas from brands like Panerai in popularity.

Key Improvements by PPF/ZF

  1. Super Clone 240 Movement
  • The first major upgrade was the development of a true clone 240 movement with a functional power reserve (unlike earlier deco-plate movements).
  • This was a game-changer, as most previous reps relied on modified Miyota movements.
  1. Updated Deployant Clasp
  • The latest versions now feature a gen-spec folding clasp, improving comfort and authenticity.

Current Market Options for the 5712

When shopping for a Nautilus 5712 replica, you’ll typically encounter three versions:

1. Stock PPF/ZF 5712 (Best Value)

✅ Pros:

  • Reliable super clone 240 movement (functional power reserve).
  • Good dial & hands (though not perfect).
  • Latest clasp upgrade (matches gen).

❌ Cons:

  • Dial color slightly off (gray tint differs from gen).
  • Hands have a hollow axis (not solid like gen).

2. PPF 5712 + SW Dial & Hands (Best Overall Upgrade)

✅ Pros:

  • SW dial has a more accurate color (closer to gen).
  • SW hands feature a solid axis (better than stock PPF).
  • Still uses the stable PPF 240 movement.

❌ Cons:

  • More expensive (SW parts add cost).
  • Requires sourcing and installation (some dealers offer pre-modded versions).

3. Full Custom 5712 with ACE 240 Movement (High-Risk, High-Cost Option)

✅ Pros:

  • Movement decoration is stunning (engravings nearly identical to gen).
  • Free-sprung balance wheel (like genuine 240).
  • 18K solid gold micro-rotor (luxury touch).

❌ Cons:

  • Extremely expensive (costs thousands of USD).
  • Unreliable accuracy (free-sprung balance lacks adjustability).
  • Stability concerns (untested long-term).

Which Version Should You Buy?

FactorStock PPFPPF + SW Dial/HandsACE 240 Custom
Movement Stability✅ Reliable✅ Reliable❌ Unproven
Dial Accuracy❌ Slightly off✅ Near-gen✅ Near-gen
Hands Quality❌ Hollow axis✅ Solid axis✅ Solid axis
Price💲 Affordable💲💲 Moderate💲💲💲💲 Very Expensive
RecommendationBest for budget buyersBest overall choiceOnly for collectors willing to risk reliability

Final Verdict

  • For most buyers: The PPF 5712 + SW dial & hands offers the best balance of accuracy and reliability without breaking the bank.
  • If you want stock reliability: The base PPF version is still excellent.
  • Avoid the ACE 240 custom unless you’re a hardcore collector willing to gamble on stability.

What’s your take?

  • Would you go for the SW-upgraded version, or stick with stock PPF?
  • Have you tried the ACE 240 movement? Share your experience below!

PPF Nautilus Moon Phase 5712

In recent years, one of the super clone watches that have been mostly improved in the market is Nautilus Moon Phase 5712, which is made by PPF, actually it is also ZF. I thought they were two different factories when there was a news saying that they cooperated and developed the V2 Edition of 5712 in last year, actually PPF and ZF are the same watch maker. This replica watch is also one of the best sellers in 2024, I think it is more popular than the replicas in other brand watches like Panerai.

For Nautilus 5712, I still remembered the first improvement was made on the movement, PPF developed this super clone 240 movement and achieved the real power reserve function. The second improvement is on the clasp, now this replica is fitted with the latest deployant clasp that is the same as that on genuine watch. However, when you are looking for this watch on the internet, besides the latest version from PPF, some dealers may provide you with other options for 5712. The first option is the one with SW dial and hands, but still using the 240 movement from PPF. You can buy this one, because after being replaced with SW dial and hands, the replica is closer to genuine. Check the pictures below, the left 5712 is using SW dial and hands, the right one is the original 5712 from PPF. We can clearly see the dial color difference, and after being replaced with the SW hands, the axis of the hands is solid.

PPF 5712 vs SW 5712
https://youtube.com/watch?v=JvHIHKzd_Zg%3Ffeature%3Doembed

Some dealers may provide you with another option, which not only change its dial and hands, but also replace its movement. The pictures below just showing the movement that could be used in the Nautilus 5712. It is a completely custom-made 240 movement from ACE. Well, I do not suggest you buy the 5712 with this movement, because it is not stable. This custom-made 240 has a free sprung balance wheel, not index regulated, although this feature makes the movement look closer to genuine 240 calibre, the movement accuracy can not be guaranteed. The custom-made 240 movement also has a much better decoration on the movement plate, you can see the engravings, whose thickness and color are very close to that of genuine, the micro auto rotor is 18K gold made, solid gold. However, this movement is too expensive, need thousands of US Dollars, and its stability is so unsure, so I do not recommend the 5712 with this movement.

ACE 240 Movement

OME vs. PPF: Who Makes the Best Replica Patek Nautilus 5712?

The rise of OME, a new player in the replica watch industry, has forced PP Factory (PPF) to improve its Nautilus 5712—particularly the movement engravings, as we discussed before. But now, OME is making waves with its own version of the 5712, available in stainless steel and rose gold.

Many reviewers claim OME’s 5712 is superior to PPF’s, but is that really the case? Let’s compare them side by side.

Dial, Hands & Moon Phase Comparison

  • Left (OME Gold 5712) – Features a solid hand axis (better than hollow hands on some reps).
  • Right (PPF 5712 with SW Upgrades) – Uses SW dial, hands, and moon phase, which are higher quality than OME’s stock parts.

Key Takeaway:

  • If you want the best dial & moon phase, PPF + SW upgrades still win.
  • However, OME’s stock version is solid—no need for costly mods.

Case & Finishing

  • OME’s case is slightly thinner in the mid-section, but overall thickness matches PPF.
  • Lug finishing is sharper and more refined on OME—a noticeable improvement over PPF.

Key Takeaway:

  • OME has better case shaping, especially at the lugs.
  • PPF’s case is still good, but OME’s attention to detail stands out.

Movement & Price Considerations

  • PPF’s 240 movement has improved engravings, but OME’s movement is still under evaluation.
  • Modding PPF (SW parts) is expensive—often costing more than buying OME outright.

Key Takeaway:

  • If you want out-of-the-box quality, OME is a strong contender.
  • If you prefer modding, PPF + SW upgrades remain an option—but at a higher price.

Final Verdict: OME or PPF?

FeatureOME 5712PPF 5712 (Modded)
Dial QualityGood (but SW is better)Best (with SW parts)
HandsSolid axis (better than hollow)SW hands (superior)
Case FinishingSharper lugs, better shapingGood, but not as refined
MovementStill being testedImproved engravings
PriceMore affordableExpensive after mods

For most buyers:

  • OME offers great value—no mods needed, excellent case finishing.
  • PPF + SW is the “best” but costly—only worth it if you’re willing to invest in upgrades.

What do you think?

  • Is OME’s 5712 the new king, or does PPF still hold the crown after mods?
  • Have you compared their movements in detail? Share your thoughts below!

PPF (ZF) Announces Key Upgrades to Two Iconic Models

As a leading manufacturer in the high-end replica space, PPF (operating as ZF) has recently implemented significant refinements to two of their most sought-after timepieces – the Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712 and Vacheron Constantin Overseas 4500V. These enhancements further solidify their position in the super clone market.

1. Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712 – Movement Engraving Upgrade

The latest iteration (still designated as V3) now features:

  • Deeper, more pronounced gold engravings on the movement plates
  • Transition from surface-level printing to authentic 3D engraving
  • Comparison images clearly show the improved depth and craftsmanship

Previous Version Improvements:

  • V2: Implemented functional power reserve
  • V3: Upgraded clasp mechanism

2. Vacheron Constantin Overseas 4500V – Movement Modification

Key changes in this update include:

  • Repositioned balance wheel (now closer to 8 o’clock)
  • Slightly increased case thickness (11.2mm → 11.5mm)
  • Reversed date adjustment direction (now changes counterclockwise)

Note: While some observers report a bolder date font, this difference appears negligible upon close inspection.

These thoughtful refinements demonstrate PPF’s commitment to continuous improvement, ensuring their replicas remain at the forefront of the market. Collectors can now enjoy even more authentic details in these premium timepieces.

Images below showcase the before-and-after comparisons of these enhancements.