The rise of OME, a new player in the replica watch industry, has forced PP Factory (PPF) to improve its Nautilus 5712—particularly the movement engravings, as we discussed before. But now, OME is making waves with its own version of the 5712, available in stainless steel and rose gold.
Many reviewers claim OME’s 5712 is superior to PPF’s, but is that really the case? Let’s compare them side by side.
Dial, Hands & Moon Phase Comparison
- Left (OME Gold 5712) – Features a solid hand axis (better than hollow hands on some reps).
- Right (PPF 5712 with SW Upgrades) – Uses SW dial, hands, and moon phase, which are higher quality than OME’s stock parts.
Key Takeaway:
- If you want the best dial & moon phase, PPF + SW upgrades still win.
- However, OME’s stock version is solid—no need for costly mods.
Case & Finishing
- OME’s case is slightly thinner in the mid-section, but overall thickness matches PPF.
- Lug finishing is sharper and more refined on OME—a noticeable improvement over PPF.
Key Takeaway:
- OME has better case shaping, especially at the lugs.
- PPF’s case is still good, but OME’s attention to detail stands out.
Movement & Price Considerations
- PPF’s 240 movement has improved engravings, but OME’s movement is still under evaluation.
- Modding PPF (SW parts) is expensive—often costing more than buying OME outright.
Key Takeaway:
- If you want out-of-the-box quality, OME is a strong contender.
- If you prefer modding, PPF + SW upgrades remain an option—but at a higher price.
Final Verdict: OME or PPF?
| Feature | OME 5712 | PPF 5712 (Modded) |
|---|---|---|
| Dial Quality | Good (but SW is better) | Best (with SW parts) |
| Hands | Solid axis (better than hollow) | SW hands (superior) |
| Case Finishing | Sharper lugs, better shaping | Good, but not as refined |
| Movement | Still being tested | Improved engravings |
| Price | More affordable | Expensive after mods |
For most buyers:
- OME offers great value—no mods needed, excellent case finishing.
- PPF + SW is the “best” but costly—only worth it if you’re willing to invest in upgrades.
What do you think?
- Is OME’s 5712 the new king, or does PPF still hold the crown after mods?
- Have you compared their movements in detail? Share your thoughts below!
